Jones Day and Blockshopper.com: Trademarks or Privacy Rights?

I don't know how many people have followed the settlement in the case involving Jones Day and blockshopper.com – the case in which Jones Day sued for trademark infringement over blockshopper's reference to Jones Day associates and their property purchases.  There is a good discussion of the settlement agreement in slate.com.

I always thought that the the trademark infringement claims seemed somewhat specious.  I also find the settlement peculiar.  Under its terms, blockshopper is required to display links to Jones Day associates in a particular format, with the Jones Day URL for the appropriate associate in parentheses after the reference.  Thus, as Wendy Davis reports in Slate, instead of posting "Tiedt is an associate," the site may write "Tiedt (http://www.jonesday.com/jtiedt/) is an associate."  I suppose it's arguable that, assuming there actually was any consumer confusion, this might dispel that confusion.

However, when I first heard about the case, I had thought the concern was more about the privacy of the associates – in that they didn't want details of their real estate purchases displayed all over the Internet.  (I noted this in an interview with the Cleveland Plain Dealer last year. ) Notwithstanding that the material is part of the public record, it was protected by "practical obscurity" prior to the advent of services like blockshopper.com so was at least in some degree "private" or less then fully public.  Even if the settlement protects Jones Day's trademark, it  does nothing for the associates' privacy. 

It also opens the door to a variety of different companies making diverse requests to online services to display information about them in a certain way, thus increasing the costs of doing business online, if your business model involves reference to the activities of other businesses or their employees.  As Wendy Davis notes:  "Consider what it would mean for Web publishers if lots of other
companies decided to demand a say over how other sites linked to them.
Jones Day wants URLs used as anchor text, but it's not hard to imagine
that another company would want something else—a name or a description,
for instance. Web sites could then be forced to use different linking
protocols for every company they write about. Not only would they lose
control over stylistic decisions, but accommodating a variety of
individual requests could prove clunky and labor intensive, which also
means expensive." (Slate.com, Feb 12, 2009).

12 Comments

  1. Jeff Paul Scam

    I love the IT technology, my dad got me my first pc for my birthday and ever since I became a big IT freak. I started internet marketing for the last four months and still looking for material that can help my marketing.

  2. Traffic Building

    hey how you doing! Nice posting. I enjoyed reading it. I too run a blog on internet and traffic building, and checking out what others may have written.

  3. penis enlargement

    Are you ashamed of your small size penis? here is the top penis enlargement methods and penis enlargement products that enlarge penis size naturally in weeks at http://www.Naturalherbalz.com

  4. Penis Enlargemen

    Penis size always concern to men’s every where in every culture. In most cultures a large penis is considered the sign of virility, stamina and power. An average penis size is 5.2-6 inches. In this age of modern science various penis enlargement techniques offer penis enlargement for men. Natural Penis Enlargement

  5. penis enhancement

    This is one of the best blog, i have ever seen in my life, really impressive work by webmatser, i must wanna share my views about this posting, that very low rang of people talk about this in public forum so hats off to blogger. thnx.

  6. orderpenisenlargement

    Top Rated – Best penis enlargement – Pills, Devices, Patch and Exercises, Really working Can increase the growth of the penis up to 7-9 inches, without side effects, 100% Money Back Guarantee!!!!

    http://www.orderpenisenlargement.com

  7. youtube music

    This article is very interesting. Thank you very much for sharing .

  8. buy viagra

    hey friend amazing information about Jones Day and Blockshopper.com: Trademarks or Privacy Rights? I'm very interesting in this post and I would like to have any update about Blockshopper.

  9. giovanni

    you can do something about it! easily! you don't even need an attorney. you will affect them where it hurts the most.

    google and other search engines will take them down.

    read up on DMCA act and submit the infringing material to each search engine. just because they claim that something is public information DOES NOT give them the right to repost it. Google and the other search engines have a legal responsibility to take their entire site down.

    good bye blockshopper. it's perfectly legal and there is nothing they can do. the entire site will be gone.

  10. fredyz

    I really liked the world of IT and even I also run a blog on the internet and building traffic, and check out what other people may have been written.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *